"We have seen an increase in the amount of people bringing any cash savings they have out of Greece (and Spain) but the bigger concern is for those who have their money tied up in assets such as property and business," says Stephen Hughes of Currencies.co.uk.
Exchange controls are not a rarity as Charles Purdy, managing director of Smart Currency Exchange, points out: "Having worked in South Africa for a number of years, exchange control was very much a part of international trade. But fund flows in the eurozone are supposed to have no such limitations. The trouble is that in times like this, with so much uncertainty surrounding the long term viability of banks in the southern states, funds are moving north to safe havens. This is very difficult to stop legally."
Simon Smith of FxPro says the numbers show the evidence of money going elsewhere: "In Switzerland, it's in the 28pc rise in FX reserves seen in May so as to defend the franc cap against the euro. In Germany, it's in the property market.
"If Greece were to exit the euro, at some point capital controls would have to be imposed, to stop money leaving the country while a new currency was introduced."
Already Europe's finance ministers have discussed imposing capital controls, putting in border checks on the movement of money and limiting withdrawals from bank cash machines.
Jeremy Cook of World First preaches calm, saying: "We're naturally going to see some deposit flight from countries that are in the spotlight, but statements that this is a new phenomenon and that people are moving their money out of the eurozone en masse are inaccurate and unhelpful.
"We are not seeing a run on banks in Greece at the moment; deposits have been walking away for the past two years, and are unlikely to come back. Spanish money is also slipping out of the country and will continue to do so without some form of backstop, but there is no need to press the panic button."
Introducing controls on the movement of money across the eurozone goes against the core principles of the union, as Alistair Cotton of Currencies Direct says. "It will be very difficult in practise for the eurozone to stop the flow of money from the weaker peripherals to the more stable German core.
"It is in Germany's interest to keep all eurozone members in the euro. Whether there is a full scale bank run in the periphery rests on the Bundesbank's tolerance for the liabilities to keep building, and at the moment they have no choice."
Forex focus is sponsored by
Doris Money, what bank called Farepak savers' cash as thousands who lost out in scandal are cheated out of justice - Daily Mail
- When firm went into administration cash was used towards repaying the bank's 31million loan
|

Anger: Thousands of Farepak Christmas hamper customers were cheated out of justice yesterday
Thousands of customers who lost money in the Farepak Christmas hamper firm scandal were cheated out of justice yesterday.
As a high-profile court case against the directors of the failed firm collapsed, it emerged that bankers had referred to customers' cash as 'Doris money'.
It was also revealed that bankers, HBOS, twice refused to protect 4million saved by customers, mainly on low incomes, to buy a hamper.
The Insolvency Service abandoned its five-year Farepak investigation after extraordinary new evidence showed that HBOS turned down the option of placing the money in a trust.
This meant that when the firm collapsed into administration in 2006 the cash was used towards repaying the bank's 31million loan rather than refunded to Farepak's vulnerable customers, many of them elderly.
More than 150,000 customers who had paid regular instalments for a Christmas hamper were left on average 400 out of pocket and offered just 15p in the pound.
Hugely embarrassing emails from senior bankers at HBOS, which is now owned by Lloyds Banking Group, showed they referred to the cash from Farepak's vulnerable customers as 'Doris money'.
The new evidence will heap further pressure on Peter Cummings, known as the banker to the stars of the financial world, who was handed a 'warning notice' and punitive fine by the Financial Services Authority in April as part of its investigation into HBOS.
It has been reported that Mr Cummings, who is challenging the FSA's rebuke, had been the 'ultimate arbiter' of what happened with Farepak.
This is the second collapse of a case brought by a government department this week – the Insolvency Service falls under the responsibility of the Department of Business.

Rich pickings: When the firm went into administration in 2006 the cash was used towards repaying the bank's 31million loan not vulnerable customers
On Monday the Serious Fraud Office dropped its investigation into property tycoon Vincent Tchenguiz.
On Farepak, lawyers representing the Insolvency Service had asked Mr Justice Peter Smith in the High Court to disqualify its former bosses from being company directors, accusing them of 'unfit conduct'.
The former bosses, including Sir Clive Thompson, an ex-president of the Confederation of British Industry, contested the disqualification applications.
But yesterday the government's companies watchdog abandoned its bid to penalise the directors after the new evidence emerged that included the fact that they had twice tried to protect the cash of customers.
Business Secretary Vince Cable said he felt 'huge' sympathy for 'those who lost out' and would reflect on the decision by the Insolvency Service.
A spokesman for Lloyds Banking Group said: 'As this matter is subject to ongoing legal proceedings, it would be inappropriate to comment.
'We have assisted the relevant authorities at all times during their investigation of European Home Retail plc and Farepak and the conduct of their directors.'
Rangers crisis: Ibrox season ticket renewal money held by 'oldco' - Stv.tv
Ibrox season ticket renewal money is being paid into and held by the soon-to-be-liquidated 'oldco' Rangers.
The Sevco group that formed a new business entity to purchase the club’s assets confirmed it is using Rangers FC plc, incorporated in 1899, to receive any season ticket renewal cash paid over.
Rangers claim the money is being held by the old company, which is still under the control of administrators Duff and Phelps, and will be later transferred to new business entity, Sevco 5088 Limited, as part of the deal reached with the consortium led by Charles Green.
Direct debit payments for around 30,000 season tickets are being processed after renewals were sent out by the club on June 8.
A spokesman for Rangers said: "The season ticket renewal direct debits have been operated within the old company until they are transferred to the new company in an ongoing process that will be completed in due course."
Mr Green previously stated that the season ticket renewal cash was not being used to fund his consortium’s takeover and that it would be ring-fenced and held in a "secure" account.
In the failed company voluntary arrangement (CVA) proposal, Duff and Phelps sought those owed money to approve that all season ticket sales and player transfer cash to be held in a bank account by their English solicitors Taylor Wessing. They sought creditors permission to the exclude this money from the payout pot, while they also stated in the CVA proposal that they may seek Sevco’s approval to use the cash to meet "trading costs" should the club have successfully agreed the pence in the pound plan.
On Thursday, the Rangers’ Fans Fighting Fund released a statement after its representatives had met with newco chief executive Mr Green and chairman Malcolm Murray.
In a statement the fund said it had "received satisfaction on the future security of the property assets, forward flow funding and the ring fencing of season tickets for the good of the club."
The fund, which is led by former player Sandy Jardine and at was launched by ex-manager Walter Smith, said it "would encourage fans to renew their season tickets at this time to demonstrate our support for our manager Ally McCoist his management team and our players."
On the back of the meeting, the fund called on supporters to "show solidarity for the club".
Mr Green added: "I can reassure all fans that season ticket money will be ring-fenced in a secure account and will not be used before the current issues surrounding the club, such as what league we will be playing in, are resolved."
Mr Green’s consortium, which is backed by investment banking operation Zeus Capital and Scottish golf clothing firm Glenmuir among others, paid £5.5m to buy the club’s assets, cover the £3m fees of Duff and Phelps and an estimated £1m for the future liquidators of Rangers FC plc, BDO. According to the CVA proposal document, this money will be supplemented by around £2m in outstanding transfer fees owed to Rangers and the cash at bank.
According to the administrators, who were appointed on February 14 after the club had failed to pay around £14m in PAYE and VAT to HMRC following Craig Whyte's May 2011 takeover, around 37,900 season tickets were sold at Ibrox for the 2011/12 season.
Mr Whyte used future season ticket sales to secure £25.3m from London firm Ticketus to effectively fund his takeover by wiping out the club's £18m debt to Lloyds Banking Group.
Related articles
- Hearts owner Romanov says no to Rangers newco in SPL
- Businessman linked to Rangers 'takeover' bid paid to play for Celtic
- Rangers crisis: Key documents in the meltdown of Ibrox club
- Rangers crisis: HMRC to investigate those responsible for meltdown at club
- Rangers liquidation now inevitable after CVA bid rejected by HMRC
People who read this story also read
- Businessman linked to Rangers 'takeover' bid paid to play for Celtic
- Hearts owner Romanov says no to Rangers newco in SPL
- Former serviceman 'tried to have sex with dog in communal garden'
- 'Stupid' man admits taking fake gun to Celtic's Lennoxtown training ground
- Rangers crisis: Key documents in the meltdown of Ibrox club
Spain to seek bank aid as borrowing costs soar - Reuters UK
MADRID/LUXEMBOURG |
MADRID/LUXEMBOURG (Reuters) - Spain's medium-term borrowing costs spiralled to a euro-era record at an auction on Thursday, before an independent audit was due to reveal the size of a capital hole in Spanish banks which will be filled by a euro zone bailout.
Euro zone finance ministers will discuss how to channel up to 100 billion euros in rescue loans to Spanish lenders weighed down by bad loans from a burst property bubble. Many in the markets see the package as a mere prelude to a full programme for the Spanish state.
"We have already started working on the design of the aid with the Commission, the European Central Bank and the International Monetary Fund," Spanish Economy Minister Luis de Guindos told reporters as he arrived for the ministerial talks in Luxembourg. "We will present the request in the next few days."
Spain's financial plight is centre stage a week before a European Union summit tackles long-term plans for closer fiscal and banking union in an effort to strengthen the euro's foundations, after bailouts for Greece, Ireland and Portugal failed to end a 2-1/2-year old debt crisis.
To pave the way, the leaders of Germany, Italy, France and Spain will meet in Rome on Friday.
Madrid sold 2.2 billion euros in medium-term bonds and attracted strong demand. But yields on 5-year paper rose to a 15-year high of 6.07 percent, a level regarded by analysts as unaffordable for any prolonged period.
The runaway Spanish yields contrasted with a French auction in which the yield on 5-year benchmark paper hit an all-time low of 1.43 percent.
"The first worry is can they (Spain) fund from the markets? They raised 2.2 billion versus a 2 billion target, so they can raise the money," said Achilleas Georgolopoulos, a strategist at Lloyds in London.
"Then the (question is), are the yields threatening for the medium term? And yes, clearly they are much higher than the previous auction ... But still they can continue for a few months to fund at these levels."
Two independent auditors are due to deliver a report to the Spanish government on the recapitalisation needs of the banking sector following last month's sudden nationalisation of Bankia, the fourth biggest lender.
De Guindos will present the findings to his euro zone colleagues in Luxembourg. Banking sources believe the report will say the lenders need to raise a further 60-70 billion euros.
"NO DEBT MUTUALISATION"
The finance ministers will discuss which of the euro zone's rescue funds - the temporary European Financial Stability Fund or the permanent European Stability Mechanism - will lend Spain the money. This matters to investors because ESM loans would be senior to other Spanish borrowing, meaning private bondholders would face first losses in any debt writedown.
The ministers are also expected to ponder the next steps with Greece, following the formation of a coalition of mainstream parties committed to the country's 130 billion euro EU/IMF bailout but determined to renegotiate some of the terms.
Athens will ask lenders for two more years to hit fiscal targets and an extension to unemployment benefits as it seeks to soften the punishing terms of the bailout saving the country from bankruptcy, a party official said.
Greek officials have said this would entail an extra 16-20 billion euros in foreign funding. It sets up a showdown with Greece's euro zone partners, in particular paymaster Germany, which have offered modifications but no radical re-write of the conditions attached to the lifeline agreed in March.
"We can always discuss conditions of the loan. But let us not forget one thing: This is not one-way development aid," Luxembourg Finance Minister Luc Frieden told Reuters Insider television.
RESCUE FUND TO THE RESCUE?
The German government and opposition reached a deal that will allow parliament to approve the euro zone's permanent bailout scheme next week, but Germany's top court may delay the rescue fund's start date scheduled for July 1, saying it needed time to study the treaty.
The ESM cannot go into effect without approval by Europe's biggest economy. Ratification also requires the signature of the president and a nod from the constitutional court in Karlsruhe.
The parliamentary floor leader of Merkel's conservatives appeared to dash French and southern European hopes of nudging Berlin towards common euro area debt issuance, saying there would be no mutualisation of debt in Europe.
The euro zone finance ministers may consider a suggestion by Italian Prime Minister Mario Monti, made on the sidelines of this week's G20 summit, to use the euro zone's rescue funds to buy the bonds of Spain and Italy in the secondary market to bring down their borrowing costs.
Monti hosts Spanish premier Mariano Rajoy, German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French President Francois Hollande in Rome on Friday and is also expected to raise the idea there.
Merkel has played down the proposal, which investors said might be counter-productive unless the ECB stepped in decisively in support.
Any cash injection would come with strings attached, equivalent to the sort of bailout programmes that Italy and Spain are trying to avoid because of the stigma attached.
Given the limited capacity of the temporary EFSF and planned permanent ESM rescue funds, with at most 500 billion euros available, a senior EU source said such intervention would make sense only if the ESM had a banking licence enabling it to borrow from the ECB. Germany has so far opposed that idea.
"Right now we have no requests to buy via the EFSF/ESM, Spanish or Italian bonds," Frieden said.
But he added: "We have funds available if necessary to help those countries in need ... We will do whatever is necessary to make sure that this zone, which is in trouble, will remain in the medium and long term a stable monetary union."
(Additional reporting by Leigh Thomas in Paris, Nigel Davies and Julien Toyer in Madrid, John O'Donnell in Brussels, Annika Breidthardt, Robin Emmott, Charlie Dunmore and Axel Threlfall in Luxembourg. Writing by Paul Taylor/Mike Peacock. Editing by David Stamp)
2006 ....its now 2012, 06 years to finaly get no justice in the end, and are any of the legal costs down to the tax payers ??
- pat, cleveland, 21/6/2012 17:52
Report abuse